Should you Invest in Adani’s Stock After They Proved Guilty in Stock Manipulation and Bribery

A few days ago, all Adani stocks saw a sharp decline, but many people couldn’t figure out the reason behind it—it just happened. Later, it was revealed that arrest warrants had been issued against the Adani Group, and they were accused of stock manipulation in collaboration with entities in America. On top of that, the Hindenburg report also surfaced. In short, a lot has happened with the Adani Group recently.

Understanding these developments is crucial because a significant amount of money, both from Indian investors and foreign investors, is tied up in Adani stocks. There’s also a concern that this could turn out to be India’s next and biggest scam.

So, should you invest in Adani Group stocks or not? Read the full article carefully to find out.

learn how to identify manipulated stocks

What allegations have been made against the Adani Group in recent years?

Let’s first go through, one by one, how many allegations have been made against the Adani Group and in how many of them they have been proven guilty. This is important to understand before moving forward.

1. Connection Between India’s Prime Minister and Gautam Adani

You might have seen numerous images of India’s Prime Minister and Adani together, where they appear to share a close friendship. Now, let’s explore how much each of them has benefited from this relationship.

A) Land Deals in Gujrat 2014

In 2014, in Gujarat, Modi—who is now India’s current Prime Minister—sold land to the Adani Group at prices ranging between Re 1 and Rs 32 per square meter. In comparison, companies like Tata and Suzuki were offered land in the same area for Rs 900 per square meter. I’ve included links and images for reference; please check them for more details.

B) Wrong classification of forest land

The Adani Group has faced allegations of misclassifying forest land to bypass environmental regulations and acquire land for their projects. This involved reclassifying areas designated as forest land into non-forest categories, allowing them to proceed with industrial activities without adhering to stricter environmental norms.

It was proven in the CAG report that due to the actions of the state government and the Adani Group, the Adani Group benefited by ₹58.68 crore.

There are many such small practices that the Adani Group is involved in, which aren’t causing any problems with the current government. However, as soon as the government changes in India and the opposition comes to power, the Adani Group’s activities, based on these practices, could gradually start to face challenges, leading to a decline in their operations in India.

2. The Hindenburg Report and SEBI’s Chief Involvement

The Hindenburg report, Adani, and SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India) have a separate story unfolding, which could very well be the plot of a movie in the future. But for now, let’s try to understand what actually happened.

A. Hindenburg Report (January 24, 2023)

• Allegation: Stock manipulation and accounting fraud
• Details: Hindenburg Research accused the Adani Group of stock price manipulation through the use of offshore shell companies. They also claimed the group inflated its financials and engaged in corruption.

B. Overvaluation and Insider Trading

• Allegation: Hindenburg alleged that Adani stocks were heavily overvalued and that the Adani Group engaged in insider trading practices to boost stock prices.

find multibagger stocks

C. Use of Offshore Shell Companies

• Allegation: The report stated that the Adani Group used offshore shell companies to hide ownership and inflate stock prices.

D. Environmental and Governance Issues

• Allegation: Concerns over the group’s environmental practices, particularly in relation to land acquisition, and governance issues that potentially violate Indian laws.

E. Debt and Financial Structure

• Allegation: Hindenburg raised concerns over the high levels of debt carried by Adani Group companies, suggesting that the company’s financial structure was unstable and unsustainable.

F. Impact on Stocks (Post-Report)

• Event: Following the report’s release, Adani Group stocks lost billions in market value. The market capitalization of Adani’s listed companies dropped significantly.

G. SEBI Investigation (Ongoing since January 2023)

• Allegation: SEBI, India’s market regulator, launched an investigation into the allegations, focusing on whether the Adani Group violated any securities laws or regulations.

H. Adani Group’s Response

• Response: The Adani Group denied the allegations, calling them “malicious” and claimed that the accusations were politically motivated.

I. Legal and Market Impact

• Event: As the investigation continues, Adani Group’s stock prices remain volatile, and the case has drawn attention from both domestic and international investors, raising questions about corporate governance and market regulation in India.

2.1. SEBI’s Chief Relation With Gautam Adani

A. Alleged Complicity of SEBI in Adani’s Activities

• Allegation: Hindenburg claimed that SEBI, India’s market regulator, may have been complicit or negligent in its duty to regulate the Adani Group. They accused SEBI of failing to take appropriate action despite being aware of possible market manipulation and violations of securities laws by Adani companies.
• Details: The report pointed out that SEBI had conducted a preliminary inquiry into the Adani Group’s dealings, but no substantial action was taken. Hindenburg suggested that the lack of substantial regulatory action was either due to incompetence or deliberate negligence.

B. Lack of Transparency in SEBI’s Investigation

• Allegation: Hindenburg raised concerns about the transparency of SEBI’s investigation into the Adani Group, particularly after the group’s stock crash. The report noted that SEBI had not released full details of its findings or investigations into the Adani Group, which left many questions unanswered regarding its role in the market manipulation allegations.

C. SEBI’s Historical Relationship with the Adani Group

• Allegation: The report also delved into the history of the relationship between SEBI and the Adani Group. Hindenburg highlighted that, historically, SEBI had not been proactive in addressing concerns raised by market participants about the group. They cited instances where SEBI’s oversight was seen as inadequate, which allowed the Adani Group’s alleged practices to continue unchecked for years.

D. Political Influence and Connections

• Allegation: Hindenburg suggested that there may have been political influence or connections between the Adani Group and key figures within the Indian government, which could explain SEBI’s inaction. The report hinted at the possibility of a “conflict of interest,” suggesting that the Adani Group’s influence over certain political figures might have played a role in limiting regulatory scrutiny.

E. SEBI’s Inaction Amidst Market Collapse

• Event: After Hindenburg’s first report (January 2023), which caused a significant drop in Adani Group stocks, SEBI’s failure to immediately address the crisis raised further suspicions about its role. Hindenburg argued that SEBI should have acted more decisively in the aftermath of the report’s allegations.

F. Request for Investigation by Global Bodies

• Event: Hindenburg called for an independent investigation by global financial regulators, including the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), to examine both the Adani Group’s actions and SEBI’s oversight. The report suggested that an international inquiry might bring more transparency to the issue.

SEBI’s Chief:

• Name: The current chairman of SEBI is Madhabi Puri Buch. She took over the role in 2022, becoming the first woman to lead SEBI. Her leadership was under scrutiny after Hindenburg’s report raised questions about SEBI’s regulatory actions, or lack thereof, regarding the Adani Group.

Impact of the Report:

• The second Hindenburg report increased the pressure on SEBI and raised questions about its relationship with powerful business entities in India. It also sparked debates about regulatory practices and corporate governance in India.
• SEBI’s response to the allegations was under intense scrutiny, with calls for a more rigorous and transparent investigation into the Adani Group’s activities and the role of the Indian regulator.

In summary, Hindenburg’s second report exposed the alleged inaction and possible conflicts of interest within SEBI regarding the Adani Group, highlighting concerns over regulatory effectiveness and transparency in the case.

Hindenburg, in its report, claimed that SEBI’s chief, Madhabi Puri Buch, was involved in the alleged stock manipulation and even acknowledged it. However, despite these allegations, no action has been taken in India so far, likely due to the strong relationship between Adani and India’s Prime Minister, Narendra Modi. But the day there is even a 1% shift in their relationship, every penny invested in Adani’s stocks could be at risk of sinking. (Reuters)

Why did the U.S. court issue an order to arrest Gautam Adani?

Let’s understand this simply: Adani is connected to the U.S. because he raised billions of dollars in funding from American investors to expand his company.

Reason Behind the Arrest Order for Gautam Adani in a U.S. Court

Background

Gautam Adani, the chairman of the Adani Group, has faced severe allegations of fraud and stock manipulation following investigations and reports from various entities, including Hindenburg Research. Adani Group, one of India’s largest conglomerates, had extensively raised capital from foreign investors, including those based in the United States. This involvement connects Adani to U.S. jurisdiction under financial and corporate laws.

Key Allegations Leading to the Arrest Order

1. Fraudulent Use of Funds

• The Adani Group allegedly misused the funds raised from U.S.-based investors, which were intended for legitimate business expansion.
• Hindenburg Research exposed discrepancies in financial statements, suggesting that funds were diverted for personal gains and to artificially inflate stock prices.

2. Violation of U.S. Securities Laws

• Adani Group raised billions of dollars by issuing bonds and stocks through U.S.-regulated financial institutions.
• Allegations include providing misleading information and concealing crucial details about the company’s financial health and operations.
• Such actions violate U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) rules and investor protection laws.

3. Offshore Shell Companies

• Hindenburg’s report identified multiple offshore shell companies allegedly linked to Adani Group. These entities were used to:
  • Launder money.
  • Manipulate Adani Group’s stock prices by inflating demand.
  • Obscure the ultimate beneficiaries of the funds.
• Many of these shell companies operated through jurisdictions known for weak regulatory oversight, impacting U.S. investors who indirectly became victims of the manipulation.

4. Lack of Transparency

• The Adani Group failed to disclose its actual debt levels, financial risks, and corporate governance issues to investors.
• Critical information about ownership stakes and related-party transactions involving Gautam Adani’s close associates was allegedly hidden.

5. Impact on U.S. Investors

• Several U.S.-based institutional and retail investors suffered massive losses after the Adani Group’s stocks plummeted following the allegations of fraud.
• The involvement of U.S. financial institutions in raising capital for Adani Group ties the case directly to U.S. jurisdiction.

Legal Basis for the Arrest Order

• Under U.S. laws, any foreign individual or entity that engages in fraud, market manipulation, or misrepresentation to U.S. investors can be held accountable.
• Gautam Adani’s personal role in the alleged financial misconduct makes him liable under:
  • U.S. Securities Act of 1933 for misrepresentation during bond issuance.
  • U.S. Exchange Act of 1934 for stock price manipulation and insider trading.
  • Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) for possible bribery and corruption allegations tied to international dealings.

Recent Developments

• A U.S. district court issued an arrest warrant for Gautam Adani based on complaints filed by affected investors and regulatory bodies.
• The court has directed international agencies, including Interpol, to assist in the enforcement of the warrant, considering Adani resides outside the U.S.
• The involvement of Adani Group’s financial transactions in American banks and stock exchanges strengthens the case against him.

Potential Consequences

• Gautam Adani could face extradition proceedings if India’s legal framework cooperates with the U.S. order.
• The case may lead to global investigations involving other jurisdictions where Adani Group has business operations.
• Investors in the U.S. are seeking compensation for their losses through civil lawsuits, which could further pressure Adani Group to comply with legal proceedings.

The U.S. court has indeed issued an arrest warrant for Gautam Adani, but no arrest has been made so far. This raises significant concerns about the influence and protection that politicians continue to provide to such businessmen. If this pattern persists, where political leaders shield powerful corporate figures from accountability, India may soon face another major stock market crash and potentially its largest financial scam.

Should You Invest in Adani’s Stock After All This?

NO

As your friend, I’d strongly advise you to stay away from Adani’s shares for now. Here’s why, with solid reasons and proof:

1. Fraud and Manipulation Allegations

• Hindenburg Report: This investigation exposed massive allegations of stock manipulation, use of shell companies, and inflated valuations. Adani’s businesses are accused of artificially boosting share prices, which is unsustainable and risky.
• Proof: Multiple offshore shell companies linked to Adani Group were reportedly used to inflate the stock’s demand. Such practices are unsound and can lead to significant losses once exposed.

2. High Debt Levels

• Fact: Adani Group’s debt as of 2023 was over ₹2 lakh crore. Much of this debt was secured through pledging shares as collateral. If stock prices fall, it can trigger margin calls, forcing a sell-off and crashing the stock further.
• Proof: Credit agencies and analysts have flagged the group’s debt as unsustainable, with significant risks of default if cash flows are affected.

3. Political Dependency

• Reality: Adani Group’s rise is deeply tied to its close relationship with the current government. This dependency is a double-edged sword.
• Proof: Land deals in Gujarat and special contracts awarded to Adani raise questions about fairness. If there’s any political fallout, the group’s operations could face severe disruptions.

4. SEBI and U.S. Investigations

• Ongoing Scrutiny: SEBI and U.S. courts are investigating Adani for stock manipulation and governance failures. Such scrutiny is a red flag for any investor.
• Proof: The arrest warrant issued by a U.S. court and SEBI’s continued investigation could lead to hefty penalties or restrictions, directly impacting share value.

5. Stock Volatility and Risk

• Fact: Adani stocks have been extremely volatile, with wild swings based on news rather than fundamentals. Investing in such stocks is gambling, not investing.
• Proof: Adani Enterprises dropped over 60% in value after the Hindenburg report. Stocks that depend on speculation rather than business strength are not reliable.

My Honest Advice

1. Avoid the Risks: Adani’s shares might look tempting due to occasional rebounds, but the risks far outweigh potential gains. It’s like playing with fire.
2. Safer Alternatives: There are many fundamentally strong companies in the Indian stock market with clean governance and stable growth. Look there instead.
3. Think Long Term: Don’t let short-term hype ruin your portfolio. Adani’s house of cards can crumble at any moment.

Conclusion

Given the serious allegations of stock manipulation and bribery against Adani, investing in their stocks requires careful consideration. If the company is proven guilty, the stock’s value may experience significant volatility due to legal and regulatory consequences. Investors need to assess their risk tolerance, the potential long-term impact on Adani’s reputation, and its ability to recover from such scandals.

A prudent approach would be to stay updated on the ongoing legal proceedings and avoid making impulsive decisions. It may be wiser to wait for a clearer picture before committing any funds. Always remember that investing in stocks comes with inherent risks, and protecting your capital should remain a priority.

Greets to all traders!